Skip to content

Opinion: Long past the time to deal with old St. Joe’s Hospital

Some love it, some hate it, but Up Here festival organizers say the mural on the old hospital was only supposed to be temporary as they say they were under the impression the structure would be demolished in 2020
260819_KF_risk_mural_1
The old St. Joseph's Hospital transformed into a riot of colour by Los Angeles-based artist RISK. (Keira Ferguson / Sudbury.com)

When we agreed to transform the old St. Joseph’s Hospital** into Canada’s largest mural in 2019, we were under the impression the building would be demolished the following year. 

We wanted to bid a vibrant and colourful farewell to this historic landmark by turning it into a bold piece of contemporary art — an endeavour that would leave a lasting — albeit a tiny bit, very slightly, barely even noticeably controversial — impression on the Canadian artistic landscape.

Fast forward to today, and we find ourselves as disheartened as everyone by the lack of progress on the part of the property owners. We yearn for the old hospital to undergo a metamorphosis, to be revitalized and reintegrated into the fabric of our community. 

We agree with Mayor Paul Lefebvre’s urgent desire to repurpose the building. 

To many of us, the hospital holds deep significance as a place of healing — where lives have been started and mourned, where journeys unfolded. It carries the weight of countless stories and memories, making it an integral part of our community's identity.

The potential held within the old St. Joseph's Hospital is undeniable. It has the capacity to play a pivotal role in addressing our pressing housing crisis while seamlessly connecting the downtown area with beautiful Bell Park. By transitioning it into a dynamic hub of creativity and cultural expression, all our lives would be greatly enriched.

With the mural, Up Here, the artist RISK, and the team aimed to honour the memories within its walls. It’s been a symbol of hope, resilience, and the transformative power of art.

Regrettably, the delay in the building's evolution has left many of us frustrated and disenchanted. We anxiously await the fulfilment of the original promise. 

We implore Panoramic Properties to honour their obligation and swiftly undertake the necessary steps to fulfill the collective vision we hold for this cherished property. 

Only then can the hospital once again play its valuable role in the kaleidoscope of our city, reminding us of the extraordinary possibilities that arise when history, community, and art converge.

Fun fact: kaleidoscope is the word for a swarm of butterflies.

This opinion was written by staff of the Up Here festival.

**The writers of this opinion piece refer to the Paris Street hospital as "St. Joseph's" in this article. Some refer to the hospital as "the General Hospital", which was it's original name, but it was called "St. Joseph's" at the time of its closure.


Comments

Verified reader

If you would like to apply to become a verified commenter, please fill out this form.